Regulatory Developments, Special Topics in Environmental Management

Costs of Resin NESHAP Cut by EPA

In response to separate petitions for reconsideration from the Sierra Club and two affected companies, the EPA has amended its National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) for the Manufacture of Amino/Phenolic Resins (APR). The primary changes involve revised emissions limits for continuous process vents (CPVs) at existing sources and a revision to emissions standards for fixed-roof storage vessels when the emissions control system roof for the vent on the vessel’s roof is shut down for planned routine maintenance. The final rule provides the 11 to 16 facilities affected by the amendments 1 year, until October 15, 2019, to meet the revised requirements.

Plastic resin factory

teppakorn tongboonto / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

APRs are used in the manufacture of plywood, particle board, adhesives, wood furniture, and plastic parts. The EPA issued the original NESHAP for this source category in 2000. In 2014, as required by the Clean Air Act, the Agency completed its residual risk and technology reviews (RTRs) of the 2000 standards. In the residual risk portion of the review, the Agency found that the standards protected public health with an ample margin of safety. Based on its technology review, the EPA has issued maximum achievable control technology (MACT) standards for CPVs for the first time.

Petitions for Reconsideration

The Agency received petitions for reconsideration from the Sierra Club, Tembec BTLSR (now Rayonier Advanced Materials Inc.), and Georgia-Pacific. The Tembec and Georgia-Pacific petitions stated that the production-based emissions limit in the 2014 rule of 1.9 pounds (lb) of hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) per ton of resin produced was not achievable for back-end CPVs, and they expressed concern over the data and calculation methodology used to set the HAP emissions standard for CPVs at existing affected sources.

The Sierra Club raised concerns regarding the exclusion of HAP emissions data from front-end CPVs, stating that the EPA did not adequately explain why the urea formaldehyde concentrate (UFC) HAP emissions data were not included in the analysis to calculate the MACT floor for CPVs and asserting that the EPA must include all existing sources in the MACT floor analysis. Sierra Club argued that if the EPA had included Georgia-Pacific’s UFC front-end CPV, the HAP emissions standard for CPVs would have been more stringent.

Amendments

In its final amendments, the EPA addresses portions of the petitions for reconsideration, noting that other parts of those petitions will be addressed in future rulemaking. In the current action, the Agency:

  • Revised the emissions standards for back-end CPVs at existing sources from 1.9 lb of HAPs per ton of resin produced to 8.6 lb of HAPs per ton of resin produced. The EPA anticipates that these sources will likely need to install regenerative thermal oxidizers (RTOs) to meet the HAP standards.
  • Revised the emissions standards for front-end CPVs from 1.9 lb of HAPs per ton of resin produced to less than 1 lb of HAPs per hour. The EPA says it believes that front-end CPVs will be able to meet the emissions standards without additional controls.
  • Revised the storage vessel requirement with a work practice standard that minimizes emissions from the vessel during periods of planned routine maintenance (up to 240 hours per year) by not allowing the liquid level in the storage vessel to rise.
  • Extended the compliance date for the revised emissions standards for CPVs at existing sources to 1 year from the effective date of the amendments. “This compliance date will give existing sources time to install and test emissions control technologies (as needed) and to demonstrate compliance,” says the EPA.

Overall, the Agency believes the final revisions will reduce the total $4.2-million-per-year cost of complying with the 2014 rule to $2.1 million in 2014 dollars.

The final revisions were published in the October 15, 2018, Federal Register (FR).